Getting veterans hired is only half the battle—keeping them is the real challenge. In this episode of the DE Talk Podcast, host Kim Lott is joined by Army veteran, workforce strategist, and COO & Co-founder of Service to Success, Dr. Nicole Dhanraj, to tackle a critical talent question: Why did your best veteran hire just quit?
Together, they explore why the direct, mission-driven traits prized during hiring can often be misconstrued in civilian workspaces, the essential difference between cultural assimilation and true integration, and how onboarding from day one shapes long-term retention. Dr. Dhanraj breaks down her practical ‘Keep, Flex, or Translate’ framework for navigating communication styles, highlights the power of veteran Employee Resource Groups (ERGs) and mentorship, and explains why proactive stay interviews and career roadmaps are key to retaining veteran talent.
Tune in to discover how organizations can move beyond hiring initiatives to build an inclusive workplace where veteran talent thrives.
Subscribe
Apple • Spotify • YouTube Music • iHeartRadio • Stitcher • TuneIn • Overcast • Pocket Casts • Castro • Castbox • Podchaser • RSS Feed
…or your preferred Podcast provider
About DE Talk
The DE Talk monthly podcast features honest and open dialogue between powerhouse industry experts on a variety of HR topics ranging from OFCCP compliance advice to emerging recruitment marketing trends, equal employment opportunity initiatives, and insightful solutions that help infuse new life into your HR strategies.
Episode Interviewer
Kim Lott
Community & State Outreach Administrator
DirectEmployers Association
Read Bio
Kim Lott came to DirectEmployers Association in February 2023 as a Community and State Outreach Administrator, leveraging expertise gained through her time as a Veteran Program Manager with Florida’s Department of Economic Opportunity. In addition to her primary role, she also co-leads the Women’s Inclusion Network (WIN), DirectEmployers’ women’s-focused ERG.
As a U.S. Navy Veteran who experienced challenges and underemployment upon transition, she is impassioned by veterans securing employment, which allows for their flourishing. Kim’s experiences have informed many of the issues that drive her, such as the intersectionality of race, gender, and disability and the significant ways in which these issues often adversely impact employment and career trajectory. Kim is also a New England-born, Florida-transplanted, dog-loving, caffeine sippin’, pun-abusing, kindness-advocating, Christ-adoring, wife and mom to three humans and two Mini Goldendoodles.
Episode Guest
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj
COO & Co-founder of Service to Success
Read Bio
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj, is a workforce strategy expert focused on helping employers build scalable veteran hiring and talent development initiatives. With over 20 years of experience in business operations and organizational leadership, she partners with organizations to develop structured talent pipelines that connect employers with highly skilled military-connected professionals.
Through her work with ACTNow Education, Service to Success and workforce accelerator programs, Dr. Dhanraj helps employers recruit, integrate, and retain veteran talent while building the systems and strategies needed for long-term workforce success. Her work positions veteran hiring as a strategic advantage that drives performance, retention, and sustainable organizational growth.
Transcript
DirectEmployers Association (00:00):
Get ready. The DE Talk Podcast starts now. Insightful conversations and dialogue helping you put the human factor back in HR.
Kim Lott (00:08):
Welcome to the DE Talk Podcast. I’m Kim Lott, community and state outreach administrator at DirectEmployers. Today’s topic is personal for me. I’m a Navy veteran and former dual military, so I’ve lived the transition from military to civilian work, and I’ve watched my son and other family members go through it too. In my role, I work with state veteran representatives across the country to connect employers with resources that support the employment of veterans, especially veterans with disabilities. One thing I hear again and again is that getting veterans hired is only half the job. Keeping them is the other half. That’s why I’m so glad to welcome Dr. Dhanraj, COO and co-founder of Service to Success and director of operations at ACT Now Education, organizations founded by an all-veteran team to help leading companies reach and hire technical talent. Dr. Dhanraj is a veteran, a workforce strategist, and a professional speaker.
(01:10):
She helps service members navigate their career transitions and helps employers improve how they attract, integrate, and retain veteran talent. The theme of our conversation is really surrounding the topic, why your best veteran hire just quit. It’s a bold topic, but I think an impactful one that will cover why the traits that make veterans great hires can be misread on civilian teams, the difference between assimilation and integration and what managers can do in the first year to keep good people. Dr. Dhanraj, welcome to the DE Talk podcast.
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (01:45):
Thank you, Kim. It is an absolute pleasure to be here.
Kim Lott (01:49):
Wonderful. So Dr. Dhanraj, for our listeners who aren’t familiar at all with Service to Success and ACT Now Education, can you share a bit about your background and a brief overview of these companies that you co-founded and are involved with?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (02:04):
Yes, thank you for that. So as you said, I’m an Army veteran and my goodness, that was many moons ago. I still think I’m 21, but apparently not. But over the years, I started with ACT Now Education as a way when I was navigating what comes next for me, happened to stumble upon this organization. And interestingly, while I was looking for job resources and opportunities, what I found was even more powerful was a community, a community that can tell you, “You can do this and help you see your potential beyond that.” So that’s exactly what we are with ACT Now Education. It is very, very much community focused. So when you’re looking for that support, you just can’t see the trees through the fog, this is an opportunity to come and have like-minded individuals who’ve been through transitioning, who’ve been struggling maybe as a veteran, who’ve landed the opportunity, who has done great things as a military spouse, so have that inspiration and motivation there from the community.
(03:01):
Then on the education and resource side, we pride ourselves in being the resource of resources. So being able to find whether you’re looking for upskilling, re-skilling, a certification, a degree, looking for, “Hey, what are the opportunities that I can take advantage of as a veteran or looking at programs available for you depending on the stage of your career or your journey?” So we’ve created this massive community, about a hundred thousand service members, all providing free resources. Now, as we created that community, we ended up having employers reach out to us and say, “Hey, we would like to help support and give job opportunities.” And of course, that wasn’t a service that ACT Now was designed to do, it was more on the resource side. So this was why Service to Success got born. So out of the desire to help support, continue that journey from education upskilling to landing the job, so Service to Success became the vehicle of providing employers a talent pipeline leveraging military talent, and that’s whether it is in they’re still transitioning, for example, with SkillBridge or after they’ve transitioned, and also if they have initiatives on the military spouse side.
(04:18):
So you can think of the ACT Now as the educational component, helping them really upscale, re-skill, grow their career, and on the Service to Success hiring, helping companies build their military strategy, engaging with military talent, just being able to know how to approach military talent is all that we do on the Service to Success side.
Kim Lott (04:38):
Wonderful. I love how you were responsive to the need and for that out of ACT Now Education. Now we know that you’re a veteran and now in this new facility you advise employers, so you see both sides of it with both of those organizations. What made you realize the bigger problem was keeping the veterans and not just hiring them?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (05:02):
Well, I sit in this weird spot where I do get employers calling, “Hey, we need people.” And then I do have veterans saying, “Gosh, Nicole, can you help me find a new job? I’m looking to pivot. I don’t think this is a right fit.” So that was a big aha moment where, great, we help support organizations or we see this in the news that there’s big initiatives with hiring veterans, but unfortunately they end up leaving six months, nine months, 12 months. And one of the key things that I see as the main reason is that most organizations do not have a retention strategy. Retention is a system just like hiring is, retaining your service members, assimilating them, helping them understand culture, acculturating them, those are all part of a bigger system. So there’s one thing to get your foot in the door, but there is another system to keep them in.
Kim Lott (05:59):
When those employers come to you, Dr. Dhanraj, after a strong veteran hire quits, what do they usually think went wrong in their estimation? And from your perspective, what actually went wrong?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (06:11):
Let me answer that on two sides. On the negative side, most people would just deflect, right? Oh gosh, we thought it was a good hire, but maybe we didn’t hire appropriately. Maybe there were red flags that we did not see, when all of that doesn’t need to be true. It just was maybe a lack of understanding of what did we do to really make this veteran successful, to make them feel integrated? Because oftentimes, just even think of us as regular employees. If you come into an organization and you’re assessing, you’re seeing this, you may not always ask pertinent questions based on what you’re seeing. We often as employers leave people to be after three months. We are not necessarily making sure that they’re still enjoying the job. Is everything going well? The only time we start intervening is if now somebody comes and say, “Hey, here’s my two-week notice.
(07:08):
I’m thinking of quitting.” So what is really happening is not all of that. It’s not that they found a better offer, that they weren’t committed. It’s more that maybe a supervisor didn’t give good feedback. They weren’t after three months, there was just a hands-off approach and expecting if the employee needs something, they will come forward. Maybe it was the lack of clarity. Service members on their own, they’re very rigid in a good way, needing instruction, knowing what comes next. And oftentimes in the civilian world, we don’t have that level of clarity. Think about even promotion. In military, you know when you’re going to hit E5, you know you’re going to hit that O3, right?
Kim Lott (07:51):
Yep.
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (07:52):
Civilian, you’re kind of twiddling your thumbs. Nobody’s really telling you it’s based on you, it’s based on budget, but there’s no real clear path. And I think it’s that level of ambiguity, vagueness behind the scenes that many times civilian employers are not recognizing that they’re not tailored to have that retention system. So while we’re thinking, oh, they’re not committed, there’s compensation, they went to the highest bidder, it’s really our systems weren’t designed to hold onto them long-term.
Kim Lott (08:24):
We know veterans are often hired for being disciplined, direct, mission-focused. The thing is we do see once they get hired, those traits become often labeled as too rigid or too direct a few months later. Why do the same traits that initially look like strengths in the interview become problems on the team later?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (08:48):
I think on the interview, those traits can be very abstract, right? A hiring manager is probably imagining or perceiving what discipline looks like, but maybe for that service member, when they come in, they are now questioning how things are done and the supervisor manager, that sort of directness or discipline now feels like they’re being challenged. So nothing about the veteran change, it’s the context of it. So understanding again, what are these traits and how could they excel in the organization? What is my expectation of it? So let’s use your example of discipline. If every day now I’m expected to be disciplined, I come in, I’m making sure that the deadlines are met, I am emailing the team, following through, making sure everybody’s on task, but maybe somebody else is going to look at this and say, “Gosh, that person is always down our throats or there’s no room for slack or communication is so tight.” So it’s more, you know what I think it is?
(09:53):
That when these traits, they’re so valuable that we really emphasize from employers that what we want, but once now a potential candidate or employee is exhibiting those traits in the organization, guess what that it does? It exhibits or it exposes weaknesses within our system.
Kim Lott (10:15):
And that’s so disorienting for that veteran. They’re thinking they’re coming in with this strength and it is a strength, like you said. What happens when that veteran starts second guessing how they talk, how they operate, how they move, just to fit in to that workplace environment?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (10:32):
Kim, if I may add one more to that too. I think also on the veteran side, there is a level of understanding their environment, their context, the people that they serve. So for example, we are usually very militant in how we approach very straight shooters in our conversation. There’s no beating around the bush because on the medical field, beating around the bush is not going to be a good thing. If you come in and you are really direct with your conversation, your communication, and that is your dominant style, that may not be what your peers are accustomed to. It’s on both parties to understand each other’s style. If I know my dominant style is being a straight shooter and very direct, but when I come into my environment and I recognize, gosh, people are a little bit softer, how they communicate is not directly point A to B type.
(11:26):
I may need to recognize I need to morph communication skills. And then on the employer side, also recognizing, gosh, there are instances where we need to be direct, but it’s not coming from an offensive standpoint. So there is a level of understanding where is this coming from? Is this intentional? Is this the person? We talk about bringing our authentic self, but sometimes that authentic self does not get translated in the true meaning it is expected to be.
Kim Lott (12:01):
And to your point, when we’re in the military, that short, succinct, forthright speech, it’s so prized, it’s why we do it because we see that it’s effective. So it is a challenge when you move from that environment to civilian workplace. Now I want to talk a little bit about assimilation versus integration. In your estimation, what’s the difference between assimilating essentially changing much about what made us successful in the military environment? What’s the difference between assimilation and integration and what does each look like on a real team?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (12:39):
Assimilation, in my opinion, is when you change until you fit us. You have to morph, you become one of us that nobody can tell you came from a military background. That’s assimilation that you’re looking exactly like one of us. Integration on the other hand is you get to keep your core strengths. We tell you who we are, this is what we are about, our expectations. You don’t have to guess them. You can operate, you can deliver based on the goals, the mission and all of that in your current strengths. So the organization get to really see the diversity amongst us, right? We can see every person for what they bring and then how it adds that overall to the organization. To your question of what does this look like, assimilation would be coming in and just keeping everything status quo versus let’s say an EM person, emergency management, they have done a lot of training, SOPs, all of this in their military environment.
(13:48):
If they come into the civilian world, assimilation would be they just continue doing it how it was, not questioning the same process. That would be assimilation. Let’s just continue doing it in this normal culture. Integration would be, wow, Kim, your experience is valuable. Tell us how you did it in the military. What can we learn and what can we apply here? And is it possible that you can lead this project with us? That would be integration, really valuing everybody’s background, whether it’s military or not, your background, expertise, your education, that’s really what integration is for me.
Kim Lott (14:29):
Love that definition. Now, what everyday practices in onboarding meetings, reviews quietly communicate to a veteran that they need to become more like us or more like that organization if they want to belong?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (14:45):
In a meeting, assimilation would be where everybody’s at the table and though we invite feedback or we invite discussion, everybody’s kind of staying quiet because then people start thinking, “Well, I give my opinion, nothing is going to matter. Nobody’s going to believe it, or they’re going to think this is a too strong approach.” That is assimilation. You come, you’re working, you’re producing, but you’re not necessarily based on your expertise and your background. Your expertise really isn’t valued to the extent that it should. So integration at the beginning of that meeting, we’re going to look at the team and onboarding. We’re going to say, okay, in our organization, we appreciate that if you see a risk, if you see something that we’re going down the wrong rabbit hole, we identify that early. And I would love for you at any time that you can jump in on that.
(15:41):
Now, if now there’s an open invitation and Kim, you and I are on a meeting with the rest of the team and I just pounce on the team and I’m talking about it and how I approach it, now that’s a behavioral thing. That’s communication skills. So it’s how we approach the conversation we could address. So if somebody says, “Well, you shut down Nicole for giving her feedback,” well, that is maybe because of how Nicole was presenting it. All the opportunities to say, “Hey team, if you feel whether it’s a VP, whether it’s a frontline worker is going down a wrong rabbit hole with this idea, I want you to be able to share with us your opinion and why.” And that is what I think having that integration of people valuing each other.
Kim Lott (16:24):
Now, some listeners will hear assimilation integration, they’ll hear that word integration and worry that it means accommodating everything. How do you respond to that?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (16:35):
No, integration is not an exemption. When we’re looking at our outcomes, my background is strong healthcare. We’re looking at safety, we’re looking at team respect. There are some things that are just non-negotiable. How we approach our work can be negotiable. How we phrase feedback when we raise a concern, the context we give. There’s a way that we can, we call it the SBAR method, right? You give the situation, background, the action, all of that. So there are ways that we can still work within the organizational framework, but it’s not accommodating. It’s not lowering a standard. We’re just asking them to enforce their standard, but keeping your background, your expertise within the work itself. So it’s definitely not accommodating everything. It’s keeping your same standards, but bringing your spin or your expertise.
Kim Lott (17:31):
Dr. Dhanraj, let’s talk a little bit about managers and how they are assessing the behaviors that they’re seeing on the team and how they can discern if they are just due to that veteran employee being unfamiliar with the customs and the way that things are done in that job, or if it’s actually intentionally a behavior that’s hurting the team. Which misreadings do you see most often?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (17:58):
I think being blunt is equivalent to rude. Asking why would be insubordination when really somebody is trying to understand. Misreading of being quiet is disengaged. Needing clarity can come across as if they’re very rigid. So you bring up a great point with this question because oftentimes we love doing this. We love labeling behavior. That’s a veteran thing. But keep in mind, if somebody else comes from a different culture, I don’t know, let’s say somebody from Europe comes and working in your organization, they’re going to have different ways of how they communicate, their expectations, the work, and it’s no different from a military member. And think about this, if somebody worked in the service for 15 years, 20 years, that’s all they know. Most of these folks go into the military at 18, 19, 20. Then their formative adult years, they spend in the military learning about this culture, learning how decisions are made, how we address people, how we manage a critical situation, how we respond.
(19:10):
So if they now come in to a different organization, you’re going to see some of those behaviors, but you ask yourself three things really. What was the actual outcome? Who was harmed if there was something? And would I, as the manager and employee, react in the same way if I was a non-veteran? Would another person react in the same way? If it’s usually a good outcome, then the approach is what was uncomfortable, right? That’s the misreading. I would have done it like that. Let me give you a quick example. I was recently on a call with a service member talking. There was a bit of conflict, and as I was observing this conversation, the service member was straight to the point, direct, and trying to problem solve. And I am in the background, “Ooh, the civilian is not going to appreciate that type of approach.” We’re very cajoling.
(20:07):
We’re trying to save the relationship, so we’re very and intentional with our approach. So that misreading could be, “Well, wow, that person was just rude, or the way that they’re approaching it is not very engaging,” when that really wasn’t it. They’re just trying to get a solution because that’s how their approach was in the military. I think one of the key things is there was an intentional harm to the team, then that behavior will need more coaching. If it’s not different approach to work, then that may be more understanding and getting accustomed and familiar with that because maybe in your previous or the way that you work is not the same way that veteran would work. So the question of intentionality, if unfortunately it was we coach, we performance manage, we give people feedback. If it’s something quite different, then it’s more of learning other ways about doing the work too.
Kim Lott (21:09):
I want to talk a little bit more about the behaviors that you think need coaching, but I wanted to sit on that for a minute because if I could just speak for all service members for a moment, I think a lot of us, we speak directly because we see it as a kindness as well. Not only is it effective and it’s reinforced in everything we do. We say the thing, the thing happens, and that’s the way that the day moves along and the project moves along and it’s helpful, but we also see it as a kindness. So there is that disconnect, isn’t it, Dr. Dhanraj, in how we perceive it to be and how it’s received oftentimes.
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (21:44):
Yes. And you see, because there is a disconnect, it is up to us as leaders within organization to train on that disconnect. If somebody comes and they complain, “Oh, Kim was really rude and blunt to me,” then we understand. Was she really intentionally rude or was this her way of flagging a risk or making sure that all the T’s were crossed and it’s maybe the approach, we can coach on the approach, but was it truly being blunt and rude or more of an unfamiliar with that type of approach?
Kim Lott (22:19):
Now back to the behaviors that you kind of talked about that might need coaching, which behaviors are there? Can you give a name to them? I think you talked a little bit about them, but which behaviors do need that coaching and why is it that’s how they did it in the military? Why is that an unhelpful rationale?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (22:38):
Behaviors that need coaching I think will be more subjective to the organization because I cannot say to a service member, “Hey, you need to soften your approach, your directness.” But if they go into a government job or they go into as a military employee, that type of culture is acceptable. So the behaviors really that need coaching would be based on the organization that you come in. So any employee, as they come in, they’re assessing their environment, they’re looking to see how people react, how decisions are made, just really understanding how things are operating. So they’re sending really any new employee coming the first 30 to 90 days, you’re learning about the organization just as how I learned to stand at parade rest in the military. So you learn these things. Unfortunately, we don’t have in civilian world a manual of this is how we want you to speak, act, and work like the military, right?
(23:40):
You get that training at the very beginning. A lot of these things, you have your SOPs, your policies, but nobody talks to you about, “Hey, what is it like in meetings? How do we interrupt? How do we flag a situation? How do we communicate? How do we challenge?” We’re just going by what we know. That’s the main thing. So coaching coming into the organization, I think it’s up to managers and leaders to set the tone. What are the expectations? How do we do things around here? What’s appreciated? What’s not appreciated? And what’s the biggest thing to help with that? Having a mentor during onboarding so people really learn rather than assuming, and then of course not acting in the manner where everybody’s expecting.
Kim Lott (24:26):
I love that you mentioned the mentor. I feel like that is such a great resource because oftentimes you don’t know you’ve done wrong until you’ve misstepped. It’s not a proactive thing. It’s not, “Hey, do this this way, behave this way.” It’s not until after you’ve done the thing that you’re getting the feedback that that’s not the way it’s done here. So a mentor would be instrumental in helping that veteran stay on that job.
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (24:53):
And that mentor is going to help with not only integrating from an SOP and a policy standpoint, but the unwritten rules. How do we manage the workload? How do we communicate? Is the expectation to reach out after hours? All the things that are not in the SOP is what that mentor can help with as well.
Kim Lott (25:13):
Now you have a framework of keep, flex, or translate to determine when the organization should increase understanding, when the veteran employee may need to expand their behavioral range, and when both sides need clearer cultural translation. Can you walk us through how you develop that framework and alternately, how does a manager decide which of those applies?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (25:40):
Well, that definitely is going to take a lot of training to determine which applies. And again, just looking at the challenges that both the employers and veterans, I can see those challenges in between. And a lot of it is, again, comes back to perception, misunderstanding, assumptions. There’s no clarity. So what we would want to do is keep the strength that is strong, the discipline is what we want, the ability to speak up, especially in a critical situation. So if there is a safety risk, I don’t want somebody beating around the bush, come and tell me there is something happening. And there’s actually a concept of this that I teach my students. It’s called cockpit culture, and we see that infused in civilian world, and especially if there’s cultural differences, power dynamics. So there was this Malaysian flight that the co-pilot knew that they were going to crash, and he’s telling the pilot in all the roundabout ways because based on rank and hierarchy, he dare not say to the pilot, “Hey, something bad is going to happen.” So unfortunately, this is what happens in civilian world as well.
(26:47):
In a case like that, I want somebody to say, “Hey, Nicole, time out. Something bad is happening.” Or again, I think we’ve investing these resources, we’re looking to buy this equipment. I want somebody to come and be direct and say, “Hey, listen, on this strategy or this initiative, I think we need to talk about this. Here is why.” So we want to keep that directness depending on the situation. We want to keep the discipline, but the flexing part of it is coming back to that directness. We’re going to coach on the approach, your pitch tone volume, how do you get somebody’s attention? How do you say something without sounding offensive? That’s what we’re going to work on. And it comes back to the feedback that you mentioned. It is up to managers throughout that timeframe to coach when they are observing or especially when there is a team, how do we make sure that we understand words of motivation?
(27:44):
How do we get people to do the work? So that’s the keep and the flex portion. And then the translate is what I was saying in terms of there is no understanding. So allowing people to, I guess, explain their point of view, we want to listen to understand rather than listen to defend. So if somebody’s coming and say, “Well, gosh, Nicole, you were talking to Kim the other day and you were pretty direct.” So I would ask, instead of defending my position, “Oh, can you tell me how did you or why did you think so? Is there something I said that made you feel that way?” So when I listen to understand, now I can come back and say, “Gosh, there’s definitely a misunderstanding. I was very animated or passionate about the conversation, so it may have come across that way.” Translating is usually when both parties are interpreting the behavior differently, a sense of understanding, but not in the terms of let me understand and make this okay.
(28:43):
We want to make sure that we have a shared language of this is how we do things around here. So if the manager needs to step in, “Hey Nicole, well, gosh, that can be perceived a bit harshly, so next time just be mindful with your approach.” That’s how the leader steps in.
Kim Lott (29:00):
I like that example. I like that you have a conversation about it because I think as you process that through with someone, the added benefit may be that they realize there wasn’t really anything rude about the communications. It could be an opportunity for both parties to learn about that communication style, give the veteran pause to maybe reflect and decide if they want to change their style to be less direct, but for the person that’s on the receiving end of it, it may give them an opportunity to think through and see, “Hey, why am I ruffled by that communication style?” Maybe there wasn’t really anything rude about it, but just having that conversation is very helpful. Again, this is about retention. We want to keep the veteran there. So conversations, mentorship, all of that is going to get them there.
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (29:49):
One of the key things too, we talk about is communication. Usually people talk about good communication. What is really good communication? You would think good communication Communication is based on what your version of good is. I would think the same thing of bad communication, what is my version of bad? But that may not be your version of bad. When we come together as an organization, when we talk about respecting others and again, the authenticity, being able to showcase, well, gosh, Nicole is very detail oriented. Let’s understand why she is that way. Or Nicole likes to make sure all the deadlines are met two days in advance. Where is this coming from? Is this harming us? Is this hurting us? And then also if we feel that, if from a managerial perspective, we feel that this behavior, gosh, it’s great, but how it’s being projected could use a little massage, then that’s when we step in for coaching and mentoring.
Kim Lott (30:51):
Let’s talk a little bit about the first year that veterans on that job. When in the first year does that friction usually begin that you see? And what signs should that manager watch for before it turns into a resignation? Because there’s that small little window of time where those behaviors are starting to present themselves and what the manager should be keying into and looking for so that they can intervene.
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (31:19):
Before I answer that, I want to pause for any employers listening to really come back and assess what that onboarding system is like, because your onboarding is going to make or break the longevity of an employee. I like to emphasize, let’s go upstream. So after we interview, the whole goal is to keep an employee, but let’s keep going upstream and see where we could improve to make sure this is the best experience ever. People turn down other opportunities. They moved cross country. They decided to pivot into this role. So we want to make sure that when we onboard them that they feel that this was the best decision, that there is no as soon as they come in the door thinking, goodness, did I make the right decision? So Kim, you talk about let’s look at it from six months and a year out, but we should really be looking at how can we retain this person from day one?
(32:20):
I went through and I overhauled an organization onboarding recently because it’s like, listen, when somebody comes in, you want to make them feel like they’re the best thing since sliced bread. The team should know their name. Somebody should be greeting them at the door. Somebody should spend at least a half day with them. But oftentimes what happens is that we just haphazardly, and I understand, organizations are busy, there’s not enough people, but that experience at the beginning makes or breaks everything. So you ask what areas do we look for? Well, most times you’re going to feel that apprehension or you’re going to see that disengagement. They’re not asking questions. They’re not passionate. You’re not fire in their eyes. Maybe some people you see a five o’clock shadow, they’re just coming up, they’re just there, but they’re not participating. There’s no energy and they just come, they do their work and they leave.
(33:15):
If we’re not pausing to check in, “Hey Kim, how’s it going? Are things to your lightning? What are you struggling with?” If we’re not being the ones leading with that conversation, they’re just continue slipping and slipping and slipping. And we don’t want to wait until the nine month or the year check in to say, “How are things?” We need to have that constant touchpoint. And it is a lot of work on the employer side, but my goodness, once we have a system in place, retention is definitely going to be longer.
Kim Lott (33:47):
Now we’ve talked a little bit about managers, mentors, and the role that they play in this. I want to talk a little bit about veteran employee resource groups and the role that they play. What role do they play into helping that veteran succeed in that position?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (34:03):
Just like we talked about coming into the military, you have your drill sergeant, you have your manual of telling you what you need to do or how you need to portray yourself. I think it’s the same thing for those ERGs that it’s more of helping you understand the culture, the power dynamics. Cultural intelligence is huge within organization, not only organizational culture, people culture, people dynamics. I also think they need to have some sort of psychology integrated into this to truly understand what makes people tick. But those ERGs are there to help people understand the way. Why are things done this way? Why does it irritate you? And helping bring understanding in that. So if I’m saying, if I come and I am, I guess having a conversation with you, Kim, and saying, “Gosh, you know what? I just can’t understand why things take forever here or why is it that this is of critical nature that we can’t make a decision?” Well, the ERG group would be that support system where I can come and express these frustrations and then somebody helping me understand why decisions are made this way.
(35:19):
Why is it that we appear to be slow moving or why is it that we pivoted to this initiative? So helping me translate that thinking. The resource group is an opportunity for you to have that civilian manual and give you the insights of, again, all the key aspects of the organization, culture, power dynamics, communication, decision making style, how do we get promoted, the things you need to do. They are the unwritten manual for the employee.
Kim Lott (35:51):
What a great resource it could be in concert with the mentor because in that ERG, you get to see so many more veterans at that organization that are maybe one or two seasons ahead of you. I’ve been there for five, 10 years, I’ve gone up the ranks. So it’s a great model of what can be achieved there. You’ve seen these veterans that have come in and they’ve succeeded. So having access to that along with a mentor is a really great resource for that veteran.
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (36:21):
Yes. And for organizations that a lot of their employees are not military background partnering. And that’s another reason why we develop MilMentor. So you can have your employees mentor on that platform, giving insight to what it is like to work there, your employees understanding from the military perspective their challenges and just getting more insight. ERGs are one thing, but partnering external to your organization to understand, tell me more about mil spouses. Tell me more about the skills that we need and what are the skills that they have in the military. Help us translate that. How do we convert our website to more military facing language? So all of these is what’s going to help the organization succeed. And then of course internally, as you said, with the ERGs.
Kim Lott (37:11):
Wonderful. I could talk about this all day, but I know we have to wrap it up. So just a couple more questions here. Dr. Dhanraj, if an HR compliance or TA leader could change one thing this quarter to improve their veteran retention, what should it be?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (37:27):
Goodness. You speak in my love language here too. So for me, it’s less about adding more initiatives, not another hiring initiatives. What was it that we started the conversation on? Retention. We have so many veterans and service members we can hire, but what we need to focus on now is the next phase, the veteran. Take everybody, every veteran, every mil spouse that you’ve hired within the last year and still with you and ask them and conduct a stay interview. And of course, depending on the culture, it may need to be done anonymously, but help me understand what makes you stay here? Why have you decided to stay with our organization versus leave? What are our strengths? What do you really enjoy about here? How have we made you successful? Would you encourage another service member to come in here? Would you be proud to go out there and tell people about the organization?
(38:23):
And of course, person on the other side needs to listen to understand, not defend if somebody is not saying the things that they’re saying. So for that HR person, conduct those stay interviews. That’s part one. And I say part two would be give the employees a roadmap, helping them understand what are their next steps within this organization because we know our map in the military. We know with absolute clarity what is the next step. Now, there are still ambiguity and vagueness about where is my next duty station, but I know what it takes to level up. I know when my promotion is coming. I know the expectations of my job. So I think if we were to focus on those two things, finding out from your current or your previous people what makes them stay, and guess what? Peter Drucker tells us when we understand our strengths and we can amplify those, our weaknesses become irrelevant.
(39:22):
When we know what works to keep a veteran, let’s go do more of it. And then of course, they want to see their journey. They want to have a level of insight. Where am I going? Because if I have no idea whether I’m going left, right, up, or down, then sure, I’m going to start looking elsewhere to fulfill my goals and my needs as well.
Kim Lott (39:43):
Now, Dr. Dhanraj, what would you say to any veteran who’s listening to us and feeling like they don’t fit in at their new job?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (39:53):
Oh goodness. I often feel it in my heart when I hear the level of disappointments or the challenges that sometimes service member faces, which I think could be unnecessary at times. But my message would be for those who feel like they don’t fit in, is you’re not broken. Don’t shrink yourself down to nothing, just to belong somewhere, recognizing there is a difference of where you came from and where you’re going. And oftentimes it’s that translation and acceptance of you. When we’re job seeking, we want to understand this. Who are the organizations that I can integrate with and you can talk to previous employees there, current employees, have informational interviews. Let me give you a completely different analogy. I am an 86 degree loving weather, some good humidity. I would bask in the sun. Put me in that environment and I will thrive. But put me in five feet of snow, dry, dreary skies, rain every day. I will not thrive.
(41:00):
I know the organizations I would thrive because I’ve been there and done that. If you’re coming in new, you have to spend some considerable research understanding, is this the environment I would thrive? If you like that dress right, dress, militant style, you need to find an equivalent organization. However, just like me, I’ll go to Alaska and spend a few months. I know what I need to survive while there. So if you decide to go to a different type of organization, you will have to now build new skills, leave behind old skills, assimilate, not assimilate. We want a level of assimilation, but understand this culture, acculturate, integrate, all of these things. Just like if you were to move over to Paris or anywhere, it’s a little bit different, so you need to understand where you thrive before you actually apply for the job.
(41:58):
But once you’re in, I don’t want people to feel, “Gosh, I’m here by myself. It’s so lonely. These people, they’re so different.” No, it’s up to all of us now. I have to be an advocate. You have to be an advocate for yourself in that organization. Bring these things up to leadership and start talking about it. Well, first of all, gosh, there’s not many people like me. Maybe they didn’t recognize that. Maybe they didn’t know that they’re not as strong in their military hiring initiatives. You have to be the one to help the organization come to that understanding. I have been shocked sometimes where I’ve had some service members tell me, “Well, Nicole, that’s not my job. They hired me. I’m not the one to come and tell them to be different.” And that’s not what I’m asking, but what I’m saying is that if you are feeling like the lone person or you feel like you’re just not fitting in, the only way for other people to know that is if you bring that up.
(42:59):
And of course it’s the whole approach, but getting others to recognize because the employer may be completely blind to the experiences that you are experiencing. So it’s worth advocating, especially because at the end of the day, we do want to make a difference for the next hire.
Kim Lott (43:15):
Dr. Dhanraj, thank you so very much. This conversation is going to stay with me. As a veteran, I remember how much of my military self that I carried into my first civilian job, maybe my second, third, and how much it meant when a manager took the time to understand it instead of asking me to drop it or expect me to assimilate. Your point that recruiting gets veterans through the door, but integration decides whether they stay is one that every employer should hear. To our listeners, if you’re working to hire and retain veterans, you don’t have to do it alone. State veteran representatives in your area can be great partners and the DirectEmployers team is happy to help you connect with them. You can learn more about Dr. Dhanraj work at ServiceToSuccess.com and ACTNowEducation.org. And to any veterans listening who feel like they don’t quite fit at their new job, your experience is an asset.
(44:12):
Keep what serves you, flex where it helps, and don’t be afraid to translate. As we wrap up, if folks want to get in touch with you to learn more about Service to Success and Act Now, what’s the best way to connect Dr. Dhanraj?
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (44:26):
Well, definitely on LinkedIn, so you can look me up with my first and last name there. Of course, we have the Service to Success and ACT Now Facebook, LinkedIn pages as well. For employers, if you want help with your initiatives, your retention strategy, or just helping the population at large understand what you do in military terms, we can support there. If you’re looking to train service members, you’re looking to get them employed, you want to beef up your initiative, we’re all here ready to support. Thanks again so much, Kim, for having me, and I agree. I wish we can go on for another eight hours with this conversation.
Kim Lott (45:03):
Wonderful. Well, it’s been a pleasure, Dr. Dhanraj. We really appreciate you spending the time with us.
Dr. Nicole Dhanraj (45:08):
Thank you so much.
DirectEmployers Association (45:09):
Thank you for tuning in for another episode of the DE Talk Podcast. Stay connected with DirectEmployers on Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn, or subscribe to receive updates straight to your inbox by visiting DirectEmployers.org/Subscribe, or you’ll receive notifications of new episodes, webinars, events, and more.
Great insights! Thank you for sharing. I am working on a more comprehensive onboarding plan for Military talent. It was good to hear validation for things we already have in place, and I took away several other nuggets to incorporate. I am looking forward to adding guidance to our playbook around keep, flex, translate.